The commands git switch
and git checkout
in Git are similar but have distinct purposes and use cases. Here’s a detailed explanation of their differences:
1. Overview
git checkout
:- A versatile command used to:
- Switch branches.
- Restore files to a previous state.
- Detach the
HEAD
to inspect a commit.
- A versatile command used to:
git switch
:- Introduced in Git 2.23 (August 2019), it is a more focused command for switching branches. It avoids some of the confusion caused by the multi-purpose nature of
git checkout
.
- Introduced in Git 2.23 (August 2019), it is a more focused command for switching branches. It avoids some of the confusion caused by the multi-purpose nature of
2. Specific Use Cases
git checkout
- Switch to a branch:
git checkout branch_name
- Create and switch to a new branch:
git checkout -b new_branch
- Restore a file from a commit:
git checkout <commit_hash> -- file_name
- Detach
HEAD
to inspect a specific commit:git checkout <commit_hash>
git switch
- Switch to an existing branch:
git switch branch_name
- Create and switch to a new branch:
git switch -c new_branch
- Detach
HEAD
(for inspecting a commit):git switch --detach <commit_hash>
3. Key Differences
Feature | git checkout |
git switch |
---|---|---|
Purpose | Multi-purpose: switching branches, restoring files, and detaching HEAD . |
Dedicated to switching branches or detaching HEAD . |
Restoring Files | Can restore files from a commit using -- syntax. |
Not supported for restoring files. |
Syntax for New Branch | git checkout -b new_branch |
git switch -c new_branch |
Intended Simplicity | Complex and prone to misuse for new Git users. | Clear and simple for branch operations. |
Default Behavior | Can unintentionally detach HEAD if a commit hash is provided. |
Requires --detach explicitly to detach HEAD . |
4. Which Should You Use?
- Use
git switch
for:- Switching between branches.
- Creating and switching to a new branch.
- Explicit and clear branch-related workflows.
- Use
git checkout
for:- Restoring files from a commit.
- Inspecting commits by detaching
HEAD
. - Scenarios where
git switch
cannot be used.
5. Examples
Switching Branches:
- With
git checkout
:git checkout feature_branch
- With
git switch
:git switch feature_branch
Creating and Switching to a New Branch:
- With
git checkout
:git checkout -b new_branch
- With
git switch
:git switch -c new_branch
Restoring a File from a Commit:
- Only with
git checkout
:git checkout <commit_hash> -- file_name
6. Recommendation
- Use
git switch
for branch-related operations since it’s more focused and less error-prone. - Use
git checkout
when you need to restore files or for other operations thatgit switch
doesn’t support.
Let me know if you’d like to dive deeper into any of these commands!