Difference Between ENIAC and EDVAC: A Historical Comparison
The ENIAC (Electronic Numerical Integrator and Computer) and EDVAC (Electronic Discrete Variable Automatic Computer) are two of the earliest computers ever built, marking significant milestones in the history of computing. While both were groundbreaking machines in their time, they were designed with different objectives, architectures, and operational principles. Understanding the differences between ENIAC and EDVAC helps in appreciating the evolution of modern computing and the role these machines played in shaping the future of technology.
1. Background and Development
- ENIAC (Electronic Numerical Integrator and Computer):
- Developed by: John W. Mauchly and J. Presper Eckert at the University of Pennsylvania.
- Year: ENIAC was completed in 1945.
- Purpose: ENIAC was designed primarily for military calculations, including calculating artillery firing tables for the U.S. Army during World War II.
- Construction: ENIAC was the first general-purpose electronic computer, and it was a massive machine that occupied a large room. It contained over 17,000 vacuum tubes and was capable of performing complex calculations at high speed for its time.
- EDVAC (Electronic Discrete Variable Automatic Computer):
- Developed by: John von Neumann, John W. Mauchly, and J. Presper Eckert (in collaboration).
- Year: EDVAC was designed in 1944, but its construction was completed after ENIAC, with the machine becoming operational in 1951.
- Purpose: EDVAC was intended as a more advanced computer that could store both data and programs in memory, a concept known as the stored-program architecture, which would lay the foundation for most modern computers.
2. Architecture: Stored Program vs. Programmed by Wires
One of the key differences between ENIAC and EDVAC lies in their architecture and how they executed programs.
- ENIAC:
- ENIAC did not have the ability to store programs. Instead, it operated on a fixed wiring system, where the instructions for the calculations had to be manually set by changing the wiring each time a new program was to be run.
- ENIAC was not a fully stored-program computer. Programs were input via punched cards and were not stored in the computer’s memory.
- EDVAC:
- EDVAC was the first computer designed with a stored-program architecture, meaning it could store both instructions and data in its memory. This concept was proposed by John von Neumann and became the foundation for virtually all modern computers.
- EDVAC’s memory allowed it to automatically fetch and execute instructions, making it far more versatile and easier to program than ENIAC. This is the principle behind most computers today, where programs can be loaded and run without manual intervention in wiring or hardware adjustments.
3. Programming and Flexibility
- ENIAC:
- Programming ENIAC was a complex and labor-intensive process. To change the program, operators had to physically rewire the machine, which could take days.
- It was not programmable in the modern sense, as the machine was more like an advanced calculator than a general-purpose computer.
- EDVAC:
- With the stored-program design, EDVAC was more flexible. The program was stored in the computer’s memory, which allowed it to easily switch between different tasks without needing any physical changes to its structure.
- Programming EDVAC was much simpler compared to ENIAC, as the machine could load new programs and execute them without requiring hardware modifications.
4. Processing Speed and Design
- ENIAC:
- ENIAC was a decimal machine, meaning it worked with base-10 (decimal) numbers, which was not as efficient as the binary system that became standard later.
- The machine had around 5,000 operations per second but had to be manually configured for different tasks.
- EDVAC:
- EDVAC, on the other hand, was designed to operate on binary numbers, which made it much more efficient than ENIAC.
- EDVAC’s design was based on the use of binary arithmetic, which allowed for faster and more reliable computations than ENIAC’s decimal system.
5. Size and Maintenance
- ENIAC:
- ENIAC was huge—it weighed about 30 tons and occupied a room the size of a large gymnasium.
- Because it used vacuum tubes, the machine was prone to overheating and frequent breakdowns, requiring constant maintenance.
- EDVAC:
- While still large by today’s standards, EDVAC was somewhat smaller and more efficient than ENIAC.
- EDVAC’s design incorporated new technological advances that made it more reliable and easier to maintain than ENIAC, though it still used vacuum tubes, which limited its longevity.
6. Legacy and Influence
- ENIAC:
- ENIAC is often regarded as the first general-purpose electronic computer, and it demonstrated the potential of electronic computing. However, its limitations in programming flexibility and architecture made it less suitable for long-term use.
- Despite these drawbacks, ENIAC was instrumental in proving that electronic computers could perform complex calculations much faster than mechanical devices.
- EDVAC:
- EDVAC is remembered as the machine that implemented the stored-program concept, which would eventually shape the development of all modern computers.
- Its architecture, along with the ideas proposed by von Neumann, was fundamental in guiding future designs, leading to the rise of personal computers, mainframes, and the entire modern computer industry.
Conclusion: Key Differences
Feature | ENIAC | EDVAC |
---|---|---|
Development Year | 1945 | 1951 |
Design Purpose | Military calculations (e.g., artillery tables) | General-purpose, stored-program computer |
Programming Method | Manual rewiring for each program | Stored-program architecture |
Arithmetic System | Decimal system | Binary system |
Storage for Programs | No (programming required physical wiring) | Yes (stored in memory) |
Size | 30 tons, large room | Smaller than ENIAC |
Processing Speed | 5,000 operations per second | Faster with binary computation |
Legacy | First general-purpose computer | First stored-program computer, inspired modern computing |
Leave a comment